Nirvana may have been the band that put an entire generation in flannel, and
Pearl Jam and
Soundgarden both sold a lot more records, but
Mudhoney were truly the band that made the '90s
grunge rock movement possible.
Mudhoney were the first real success story for Sub Pop Records; their indie-scene success laid the groundwork for the movement that would (briefly) make Seattle, WA, the new capital of the
rock & roll universe; and they took the sweat-soaked and beer-fueled mixture of
heavy metal muscle,
punk attitude, and
garage rock primitivism that would become known as "
grunge" to the hipster audience for the first time, who would in turn sell it to a mass audience ready for something new. Though
Mudhoney never scored the big payday some of their old-running buddies did, their importance on the Seattle scene cannot be underestimated, and their body of work -- big, loud, purposefully sloppy, a little bit menacing, and even more funny -- has stood the test of time better than their well-known colleagues.
Mudhoney's time line begins in 1980, when teenaged Mark McLaughlin (who would soon adopt the
punk handle Mark Arm) formed the band Mr.
Epp and the Calculations with some high-school friends from the Seattle suburb of Bellevue; none of whom actually knew how to play at the time. More interested in goofing off, breaking things, and posting flyers for shows that were never scheduled than actually making music, Mr. Epp didn't get around to playing a show until late 1981, opening for a band called Student Nurse. Despite their legendary ineptitude (they were described as "the worst band in the world" on more than one occasion), Mr. Epp began to develop a following, and released a 7" EP in 1982. In 1983, in a bid to sound more like a real band, the group added a second guitarist, Steve Turner, who had previously played in a garage band called
the Ducky Boys. That same year they released their Live as All Get Out cassette, but things began to peter out for the group, and they played their final show in February 1984. In 1981, Arm and Turner, who'd become fast friends, also began playing in another joke-
punk band, the Limp Richerds, and briefly placed their focus on that group until the Richerds also broke up near the end of 1984.
Eager to start playing again, Arm and Turner teamed up with drummer Alex Vincent, who had played with Turner in a short-lived band called Spluii Numa, and bassist Jeff Ament, who had recently arrived in the Northwest from Montana. When Arm decided he wanted to put down his guitar and concentrate on vocals, Turner asked former-
Ducky Boys guitarist Stone Gossard to join the group, and
Green River was born. Along with fellow Washingtonians
the Melvins,
Green River were pioneers of a new Northwest
rock sound, merging the snot-nosed sneer of
punk with the minor-key thud of
heavy metal. It didn't take long for
Green River to get noticed on the Seattle
rock scene, and in 1985 the band released its first EP, Come on Down. By the time the record hit the streets, Turner had left the band to return to college (he was also growing disenchanted with the harder
rock direction the band was following), and with new guitarist Bruce Fairweather, the band set out on a nationwide tour that was little short of disastrous, in large part because a delay in the record's release had the band supporting an album that hadn't come out yet. The band survived to make a second EP, Dry as a Bone, for a new Seattle label, Sub Pop Records, in 1987 -- but by the time its first full-length album, Rehab Doll, was released in the summer of 1988, tensions between members of the band caused
Green River to split up. Ament and Gossard formed a new band called
Mother Love Bone, Fairweather joined
Love Battery, and Vincent went to law school.
Arm and Turner, meanwhile, had formed a side project while in
Green River called the Thrown Ups, featuring graphic artist Ed Fotheringham on vocals. Essentially a more extreme example of the sort of goofy onslaught Arm and Turner had let loose with Mr. Epp, the Thrown Ups brought the two friends back together again, but Turner expressed a desire to form a new band that actually rehearsed songs before playing them in front of an audience. In his spare time, Turner began working up new material with Arm and drummer Dan Peters, who had played in Bundle of Hiss and Feast. Needing a bassist, the three hooked up with Matt Lukin, who had recently left
the Melvins shortly before they left Washington for California. Naming themselves
Mudhoney, after a Russ Meyer film none of them had actually seen, the new foursome took the
punk metal formula of
Green River and
the Melvins, added a dollop of '60s
garage rock swagger and a large portion of
Fun House-era
Stooges, and ran it all through the cheap stomp boxes Arm and Turner so cherished. Turner initially expected the band to last about six months.
In 1988, Sub Pop released the band's first single, "Sweet Young Thing Ain't Sweet No More" b/w "Touch Me I'm Sick," with the EP Superfuzz Bigmuff following a few months later. The timing proved fortuitous. The indie circuit success of
the Replacements and
Big Black had created a demand at college radio and the underground club circuit for harder and heavier bands, and Sub Pop's homegrown but earnest media blitz was helping to make "the Seattle Sound" -- soon to be dubbed "
grunge" -- the next big thing, with
Mudhoney the chief beneficiary. While the band's first American tour was nothing to write home about, the Sub Pop hype machine had already begun to take hold overseas, and the band scored a European tour -- mostly dates in Germany -- in early 1989. A few months later,
Sonic Youth, who'd been big fans of
Green River, invited Turner and Arm's new band to join them for a British tour, and soon
Mudhoney found themselves the talk of the U.K.
rock press. Superfuzz Bigmuff landed on the British indie charts and stayed there for the better part of a year, and the band wasted no time returning for a headlining tour, complete with massive press coverage and riotous shows. Word of the band's rep in Europe quickly crossed the pond, and
Mudhoney were the new heroes of underground
rock by the time their first full-length album, simply called
Mudhoney, came out in late 1989.
In the wake of
Mudhoney's success, a number of other Sub Pop acts began making big noise on college radio and the indie club circuit, including
Soundgarden,
Tad,
the Fluid, and a trio of
Melvins fans from Aberdeen, WA, called
Nirvana. However, while Sub Pop was doing a fine job of creating the Next Big Thing, they weren't making much money at it just yet, and the label's financial status was one reason
Mudhoney's second full-length album,
Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge -- which found them upping the
garage punk quotient in their formula -- didn't hit stores until 1991. By the end of the year,
Mudhoney were shopping for a new label, and they could have hardly chosen a better time;
Nirvana had already taken the major-label bait in 1990, and by December of 1991,
Nevermind had made them the biggest and most talked-about
rock band in America. Soon, seemingly every band in Seattle was being offered a major-label contract, and
Mudhoney signed a deal with Reprise/Warner Bros. Their first major-label album,
Piece of Cake, made it clear that
Mudhoney's new corporate sponsorship wasn't going to change their musical approach -- but their presence on a major label seemed to alienate old fans, while the mass audience that had embraced
Nirvana,
Soundgarden, and
Pearl Jam (featuring Arm and Turner's old
Green River bandmates Stone Gossard and Jeff Ament) found
Mudhoney's work too eccentric for comfort. While
Mudhoney remained a potent live draw, their record sales during their tenure with Reprise were disappointing, though they recorded two of their finest albums for the label:
My Brother the Cow and
Tomorrow Hit Today.
In 1999, after an extensive tour supporting
Tomorrow Hit Today, Reprise announced that they had dropped
Mudhoney from their roster, and shortly after that, the band announced that Matt Lukin had turned in his resignation, citing his dislike of touring. With the release of March to Fuzz, a comprehensive career-retrospective compilation, many observers assumed that
Mudhoney had called it a day, but in 2001 the band began playing a few live dates around the Northwest, with Steve Dukich (formerly with Steel Wool) sitting in on bass. The shows went well enough that
Mudhoney decided to take another stab at their career, and Guy Maddison -- who'd been a member of Bloodloss, one of Arm's many part-time bands -- signed on as
Mudhoney's new official bassist. Arm and Turner also found time to record and tour with a side project, the garage-
blues band
Monkeywrench. When they came back together, they recorded Since We've Become Translucent and released it in the summer of 2002. The angry political and social commentary Under a Billion Suns appeared in 2006, followed by the deliberately raw, return to their aggressive roots
The Lucky Ones in 2008. ~ Mark Deming, All Music Guide
(
collapse)
